Ibn Rushd, known in the West as Averroes, was Abu al-Walid
Muhammad ibn Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Rushd al-Qurtubi. He was a famous physician
who lived and practiced in Cortoba (modern Cordova, Andalusia, Spain) between
1125 and 1198 [e]. His reputation, however, as a distinguished physician
overshadowed by the great achievements in Islamic law and philosophy.
As a warning, Ibn Rushd statues have been placed along the
ancient walls in modern-day city of Cordova and in the hall of the University
of Barcelona. He taught medicine by Abu Harun al-excavated and Abu Marwan bin
Hazbool [f], not by Ibn Zuhr as stated by some modern historians. However, he
was a colleague and a good friend of Ibn Zuhr and, also, co-author with him
[28].
The most famous medical book of Ibn Rushd is the Kitab
al-Kulliyyat fi al-Tibb, The Book of General Medicine, which Colliget famous in
Latin translation, which provides generalia drugs in seven parts [g]:
Anatomy organ
Health (physiology),
Disease (pathology)
Signs (symtomatology)
Pharmaceuticals and food (pharmacology)
Cleanliness
Therapy (therapy).
4. The scientific collaboration between Ibn Zuhr and Ibn
Rushd
As stated by Ibn abi Usaybi'a, when Ibn Rushd wrote a book
on the general topic of medicine, he was asked of Ibn Zuhr wrote a book on the
particular topic; so that the sum of the two works they will be full employment
Sina'at al-Tibb, Medical Practices [28]. This is further confirmed by a report
of two authors, their own; Ibn Rushd at the end of his book Al-Kulliyayat [28]
and Ibn Zuhr in the introduction to his book Al-Taysir [32].
Kitab Al-Taysir Ibn Zuhr by providing drug particularia
including Clinico-pathological correlation, diagnosis and treatment of diseases
ranging from head and neck, chest, upper abdomen, lower abdomen, the bones, the
general affection, fever and epidemic. This was followed by Al-Jami ', a book
of health education for patients and their families [14].
Coupled together, these two books is one of the
comprehensive full multi-author of medical books. Figures 1 and 2 show the two
editions of this book second-in-one volume printed in Venice in 1542 and 1553
respectively. Thus, it is clear documentation of the first examples of
co-author of medical textbooks.
5. The method
Figure 3: The title page of the Arabic edition of the book
Al-Taysir used in this study.
In order to evaluate the contribution of Ibn Zuhr on the
progress of the operation, the original Arabic edition of his Book Al-Taysir
(Figure 3) carefully studied. This edition was published in 1983 by the Arab
Education Science and Culture. Editor of the book, Dr. Micheel Al-Khori, the
final member of the Academy of Arabic (Majma 'al-language al-'Arabiya) in
Damascus, did an excellent job in his edition, based on four manuscrpts
Al-Taysir, one of which was copied The Barcelona just four years after the
death of Ibn Zuhr.
We translated, in the relevant excerpts in English from the
various parts of this book. In addition, references such as books, magazines
and online history of drug sources have been reviewed.
6. Contributions Ibn Zuhr for the Advancement Surgery
I. The most important contribution in this field is its
application, for the first time, an experimental methodology in evaluating new
surgical procedure, or controversial. Tracheostomy role in the resuscitation of
life-threatening asphyxiation due to upper airway obstruction remains
controversial for several centuries. According to Adams [33] and Spink &
Lewis [34], Aretaeus in the 2nd century and Caelius Aurelinus in the 4th
century did not approve tracheotomy. Therefore, although Paul [35] (7th
century), citing Antyllus (2nd century), described tracheotomy techniques,
surgery remains unpopular.
The Colliget Ibn Rushd and Thezier AbynZoar, namely Ibn Zuhr
of Taysir, preserved in the Biblioteca Histórica de la Universidad Complutense
de Madrid. This text edited online at Google Books: (Source).
This situation lasted until the era of Islam [36] when the
AI-Razi [37] (9th century) and then Avicenna [38] (early 11th century) spoke
positively of operation and perfected techniques. Although AI-Razi talking
about tracheotomy as a drastic measure, he reported seeing a patient with a
wound in the throat where the breathing out, but the wound finally healed and
the patient survived. Al-Zahrawy [h], in his book Al-Tasrif Liman 'Ajaz' an
al-Ta'lif reported from his own experience of the successful management of
suicide trachea was cut wounds and concluded that tracheotomy is not a
dangerous procedure. However, controversy continues in the time of Ibn Zuhr who
viewed tracheotomy was, therefore, not being performed on patients who really
needed it [42]. To resolve the controversy and proved tracheotomy that is a
safe operation, Ibn Zuhr decided to conduct an experiment determining the
following (as translated from page 149 of Al-Taysir) [42]:
"Earlier in my training when I read the opinions of
(controversial), I cut the pipe goat lung after scraping the skin and cover
sheath underneath it. Then I was completely cut off the substance of the
pipeline, an area just less than the size of tirmisah (lupine seeds). Then, I
continued to wash the wound with water and honey until healed and (animal)
totally recovered and lived for a long time. "
This unique experiment is a further step in the development
of experimental school was started by Al-Razi (Rhazes) of Baghdad in the 9th
century known to have given dose of mercury monkeys to test a drug for human
use [i]. However, we think that Ibn Zuhr can still be given the title
"Father of Experimental Surgery."
Ibn Zuhr application of experimental animal models for
clinical problem is the forerunner of the methods that many surgical procedures
have been developed. The writers who came after him in the 13th century such as
Al-Baghdadi [46] and Ibn Al-Quff [47] recommended a tracheotomy
unconditionally, upper airway obstruction that is threatening not reduced by
other means, and illustrates the technique with more fixes and in more detail.
mid 16th century Ibn Rushd and Ibn Zuhr medical treatises:
Averroe - Avenzoar, Colliget Averrois Cordubensis libri VII ... Eiusdem
Averrois commentaria in Avicenna ... Eiusdem Averrois Tractatus de Theriaca,
nunquam Antea impressus ... Marci antonii Zimarae Solutiones Contradictionum
The dictis Averrois Super Colliget. Abimeron Abynzoahar, omnia nunc SUmmo
diligentiaque emendata studio. Venetijs, apud Iuntas, 1553. (Source 1 - Source
2).
Ibn Zuhr investigative mind and reliance on experiments in
the search for evidence, as well, as shown in other parts of his book
Al-Taysir. Facing difficulties do not have good treatment for patients with
severe pulmonary ulceration, he heard from a shepherd who also get a similar
disease and no cure for it. Here is a translation of the 129 pages of Al-Taysir
[48] shows how he investigated further this clinical problem:
"So the cure for pulmonary ulceration around in nature
but unknown to us. For (as) sheep when caught with a lung disease that left the
herd and roam around as if searching for something; shepherds said to crops to
eat and when they eat it their disease fully relieved and back to normal ... I
checked the lungs of sheep with the effects of a clear violation of continuity
and with clear evidence of healing and union. Until now I do not know the drug;
and I think no one before I knew it was good. "
Therefore, Ibn Zuhr was forced to post an autopsy on sheep
for clinical research on lung disease ulcers. From this quote, and from several
other places in the book, it seemed to him, too, pathologist jelly.
The second important contribution of Ibn Zuhr on the
progress of the operation is a great emphasis on the importance of practical
knowledge about anatomy for surgical trainees. Here is a translation of his own
words on page 141 in the management of inflammatory swelling of the neck when
ripe and ready to explode or drainage [49]:
"And if you have mastered the science of dissection and
drain with a scalpel in a way that you will not find a vein, artery or nerve
injury or anything that would cause additional damage to the patient. But if
you are one of a group of like me and do not practiced dissection but knew it
was only with imitation, abstain from any knife as you know the sheer
imagination will be the same in real life; especially in the case of a small
organ. "
This quote shows that only practitioners who practice
dissection himself and who has the right to master the science of operative
intervention. Master anatomy, according to Ibn Zuhr, is important training for
surgeons.
The importance of anatomy for surgical training, once again,
another prominent feature of Medical Education during the Islamic Era. Al-Razi
[50], in Baghdad, Ibn Sina [51] in Hamadan and Al-Zahrawi [j] in Cordova did
stress the importance earlier. And, Ibn Rushd, Ibn Zuhr co author, states that:
"Everyone who practices anatomy will increase faith in God [28]:
From the religious point of view, this statement by Ibn
Rushd is very important, especially because he, at the same time, the Grand
Qadi (Chief Justice) of Cordova and well-known authority on Islamic law
throughout the Muslim world; then, and until now [k] Thus, the statement
asserts that, contrary to long [59], the practice of dissection for medical
teaching is not forbidden in Islam [60].
Figure 4c: Home of the Latin edition of the mid-16th
century, Ibn Rushd and Ibn Zuhr medical treatises: Averroe - Avenzoar, Colliget
Averrois Cordubensis libri VII ... Eiusdem Averrois commentaria in Avicenna ...
Eiusdem Averrois Tractatus de Theriaca, nunquam Antea impressus ... Marci
antonii Zimarae Solutiones Contradictionum in dictis Averrois Super Colliget.
Abimeron Abynzoahar, omnia nunc SUmmo diligentiaque emendata studio. Venetijs,
apud Iuntas, 1553. (Source 1 - Source 2).
, Another important contribution of Ibn Zuhr on the progress
of the operation is the insistence on adequate training program supervised and
structured for surgeons-to-be, before allowing him to operate independently.
This again is quite clear in many places the book Al-Taysir. Just as an
example, here is a translation of page 27 in the section head injury after Ibn
Zuhr stated indications and surgical techniques trephine [61]:
"But I did not mention it hoped to see between people,
practitioners who are good at it; have sufficient skills, experience and
training. Indeed, no one should consider doing so unless he has been practicing
as a student under the direct supervision of a teacher ( bayna yaday
mu'allimehi) for a long time. Then practice alone for sometime ".
His Works
Most of Ibn Rushd's works are only available in Arabic and
many have been published:
• Bidayat al-Mujtahid wa al-Muqtasid Nihayat (fiqh of the
Sunni
Schools of thought) - now available in English.
• Al-Damima (Addendum to the preceding)
• min Kitab al-Fasl fi al-Kulliyyat Sihha (Book of Medicine
from 107Muslim Scholars and Scientists
Aristotle's Universals)
• Al-Kashf `an al-Lim Manahij fi` Aqa'id al-Milla (Islamic
Doctrine and Its Proofs)
• Al-Kulliyyat (Aristotle's Universals)
• Muqaddimaat Ibn Rushd (Marginalia on al-Tannukhi's Great
Compilation of Maliki Fiqh)
• Tahafut al-Tahafut *
• Talkhis al-Khataba (Oratory)
• Talkhis al-Safsata (sophistry)
• Talkhis Kitab al-Hass wa al-Mahsus and Talkhis Kitab
al-nafs (Aristotle on the Soul)
• Talkhis Kitab al-jadal (Aristotle on Logic)
• Talkhis al-`Ibara (Rhetoric)
• Talkhis Kitab al-Shi`r (Aristotle's Poetics)
• Talkhis Kitab al-Maqulat Talkhis ma Ba`d al-Tabi`a
(Aristotle's Metaphysics)
• Rasa'il (Epistles)
• Fasl al-Maqal bayn ma fi al-shari`a wa al-hikma min
al-Ittisal (Relationship of Law with Philosophy)
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar